3 Reasons Why...

The Dolphins Should have Passed on Hard Knocks

by Jeff Jones

Top notch athletes.  Intriguing storylines.  And, Antonio Cromartie struggling to name all of 9 of his kids.  Many of us know (and love) the HBO series Hard Knocks, but just because it’s an entertaining watch for me doesn’t mean it’s the right show for all sports fans.  And similarly, just because it was done well by the Cowboys, Jets, and others, doesn’t mean it’s the right fit for all NFL teams.  The Dolphins are one of those poor fits for AT LEAST three reasons.

1. Private Politics will be Public: The Dolphins are one of a handful of organizations that enters OTAs with a QB controversy on its hands – joining the Browns, Titans, and Jets to name a few.  What separates the Dolphins' battle from these others?  We don’t know who has the upper hand!  Garrard, Moore, and rookie Ryan Tannehill all seem to be relatively even going into pre-season activities. 

Why is this a bad thing?  Well, Hard Knocks’ audience members will probably watch Tannehill get outplayed in camp and still “win” the starting position over the two older, less-coveted veterans.  Similar political moves take place camps all over the NFL, but those other 31 teams and those other players won’t be the biggest storyline on HBO for several weeks in August and September… Shady NFL politics: 1 Miami Dolphins: 0

2.  Rookie Head Coaches have Enough to Deal With:  Hard Knocks has a way of polarizing the images of those involved.  Some coaches/players leave with many more loyal fans, while others are vilified by the public – as we saw with the scrutiny that followed Rex Ryan after his appearance on the show two years ago.  Having to worry about potential damage to his image, tending to a very public QB controversy, all while rebuilding a franchise that seems destined for mediocrity is a tough task to ask of any head coach.  Add the fact that this will be Joe Philbin’s first year as the head man in charge, and this seems certain to be a recipe for disaster… Sabotage of a young head coaching career: 1 Miami Dolphins: 0

3.  Unrealistic Expectations:  I fully realize that no NFL team or player can/should enter camp thinking that they will go 0-16 – but on that same note, it’s important to maintain realistic, achievable expectations.  Apparently no one told Dolphins LB Karlos Dansby about the importance of setting attainable goals.  Dansby openly stated that he is “expecting us [the Dolphins] to win the AFC, period.  Point Blank.” 

Excuse me?!

The same Dolphins who opened last season with an impressive 0-7 record, failed to beat a single playoff team, and lost their leading receiver AND their leading tackler (neither of whose names happen to be Karlos Dansby) in the offseason?... good luck with that.

This is not the first time the talented defenseman has seen the world through rose-colored glasses.  Who can forget Dansby proudly asserting “I’m better than everybody!” when asked to compare himself to other linebackers during a post-game interview in 2011.

As a huge fan of the Auburn Tigers – and their alumni – I must say I do have a soft spot for Dansby’s confidence… err, overconfidence.  But confidence like this, combined with a stage like Hard Knocks, can easily lead to complacency – which can be the downfall of even highly talented, worthwhile teams… Boastful overconfidence: 1 Miami Dolphins: nil.